12/10: Updated my pack again.
This version includes:

Pro Wrestling for NES:
Fighter Hayabusa
Star Man
Kin Corn Karn
Giant Panther
The Amazon
King Slender
The Great Puma

Miscellaneous:
Smokey the bear
Mike Tyson (someone's from FPD, ported over)
Wesley Willis
Randy West
Ron Jeremy
Alex Sanders
Vince Voyeur
Whitey (an original "creation", he's pretty damn bright)
Anti-Whitey (Whitey's arch-enemy)
Skeletor
Little Mac
Ace
Gary
Spider-Man (look from CROSSOVER)
Jason Voorhees (also from CROSSOVER)
Luigi (original, based on a picture from CROSSOVER)
Mario (see Luigi)
Michael Cole (beat up everyone's favorite announcer!)
Pete Gas (Mean Street Posse;)
Rodney (don't mess with 'em!)
Colonel Sanders (I couldn't resist)
Cyclops (yet another from the genius at CROSSOVER)
Gene Snitsky (updated look from naya's edit)
Hardcore Holly
Akebono (based off the template someone posted a link to)
Perry Saturn

Spike Offical Edits from FPD:
Scotty 2 Hotty
Brian Lawler
Randy Couture
Kaoru Uno
Candy Okutsu
Akira Shoji
Valentijn Overeem

chris.murders FPD ports of some Tigers, ported yet again to FPR
Super Tiger
Tiger Mask 2
Tiger Mask 3

3 of the edits I saw Phil isn't doing from FPW2:
Bruce Lee
Chuck Norris
Rocky Balboa

Ports of the FPD edits from the KUMA website:
Dan Devine (ex-NJPW)
Guy Mezger
Frank Shamrock
Tito Ortiz
Merlos Koonen (winner of the first ReMiX women's MMA tourney)
Verne Gagne
Bobo Brazil
Kerry Von Erich
Billy Robinson
Bruno Sammartino
Adrian Adonis
Don Leo Jonathan
Crusher Lisowski
Nick Bockwinkel
Kintaro Oki

All have stats, logic, and moves. Have fun with em!